JPA Identifier Generation Strategy

JPA provides flexible options for generating primary key identifiers, ensuring compatibility with various database configurations. Understanding these strategies is crucial for efficient and portable application design.

1. Automatic ID Generation (AUTO)

The AUTO strategy lets the persistence provider choose the best generation mechanism based on the database and environment.

@Id
@GeneratedValue(strategy = GenerationType.AUTO)
private long id;

When to Use:

• When you want the provider to handle identifier generation automatically without worrying about specifics.
• Ideal for quick development and testing.

2. ID Generation Using a Table (TABLE)

The TABLE strategy uses a dedicated table to manage unique identifiers. This approach is portable and allows multiple entities to share the same table for ID generation.

Table Setup

CREATE TABLE ID_GEN (
  GEN_NAME VARCHAR2(20) NOT NULL,
  GEN_VAL NUMBER NOT NULL,
  CONSTRAINT ID_GEN_PK PRIMARY KEY (GEN_NAME)
);

JPA Implementation

@TableGenerator(
    name = "EmpGen",
    table = "ID_GEN",
    pkColumnName = "GEN_NAME",
    valueColumnName = "GEN_VAL",
    pkColumnValue = "Emp_Gen",
    initialValue = 10,
    allocationSize = 5
)
@Id
@GeneratedValue(generator = "EmpGen")
private long id;

Key Elements:

• table: Name of the table storing IDs.
• pkColumnName: Primary key column name.
• valueColumnName: Column storing the last allocated ID.
• pkColumnValue: Identifier for this entity in the table.
• initialValue: Starting value for ID generation.
• allocationSize: Number of IDs to preallocate for performance.

When to Use:

• When database sequences or identity columns are unavailable.
• When you need to share ID generation logic across entities.

3. ID Generation Using a Database Sequence (SEQUENCE)

The SEQUENCE strategy leverages the database’s native sequence feature for ID generation.

Sequence Setup

CREATE SEQUENCE EMP_SEQ 
MINVALUE 1 
MAXVALUE 999999999999 
INCREMENT BY 1;

JPA Implementation

@SequenceGenerator(
    name = "EmpGen",
    sequenceName = "EMP_SEQ",
    initialValue = 1,
    allocationSize = 5
)
@Id
@GeneratedValue(generator = "EmpGen")
private long id;

When to Use:

• When the database supports sequences.
• Ideal for efficient and high-performance ID generation.

4. ID Generation Using Database Identity (IDENTITY)

The IDENTITY strategy uses the database’s identity column to generate IDs. This approach is simple but less flexible since IDs are generated at insert time.

@Id
@GeneratedValue(strategy = GenerationType.IDENTITY)
private long id;

When to Use:

• When working with legacy schemas or databases without sequence support.
• For use cases where identifier preallocation is unnecessary.

Comparison of JPA Generation Strategies

Conclusion

Choosing the right JPA identifier generation strategy depends on your application’s needs, database compatibility, and performance considerations. Use AUTO for simplicity, TABLE for portability, SEQUENCE for efficiency, and IDENTITY for straightforward cases.

Do you need assistance implementing JPA in your project? Let me know! 😊

Ahmad Gohar

With over 18 years of experience in software architecture, Java technologies, and leadership, I specialize in crafting scalable, future-proof solutions for global organizations. Whether it’s transforming legacy systems, building cutting-edge cloud-native applications, or mentoring teams to excel, I’m committed to delivering value-driven results.

See Full Bio